Follow Dylan on G+ Watch Dylan on YouTube Follow The Dylan Brody RSS feed Join the Conversation on Twitter Follow Dylan on Facebook

Commentary for This Week's CCCP on WBAI, Pacifica Radio (NY)

Dylan Brody - Tuesday, June 26, 2012

This week the Supreme Court said that Montana cannot limit the power of corporations to act as if they were people. And by "act as if they were people," I mean throw their weight around for their own benefit. 
A friend of mine is a republican and when I mentioned that I thought the idea that corporations are people was absurd, he said that corporations are made up of people and should therefore be treated as people. I wouldn't have a problem with that if - you know - it made any sense at all. A lot of things are made up of people. Chess clubs are made up of people. The Ku Klux Klan is made up of people. Soylent green is people. It's people! I don't think anyone is arguing that the Society for Creative Anachronism should have a say in the workings of our national government just because it is made up of people. 
If corporations are people, all groups of people should be treated as people, and yet the same Judiciary and Legislative organizations that wish to give personhood to corporations are perfectly willing to disenfranchise groups that are less likely be valuable allies in elections. Forgive me for seeking consistency in our definitions. But wait. If corporations have personhood, does that personhood begin at the moment that a corporation is conceived? Can the abortion of a business plan that seems unprofitable be seen as murder or does it not become murder until the corporation is fully funded? Wouldn't personhood of corporations make Bain Capital a serial murderer and, as such, subject to incarceration? Or are corporate people subject to different laws from corporeal people? 
  Ultimately, the question of personhood is a clever misdirection when it comes to Citizens United. The real point of the ruling is that money equals speech. The unspoken but dangerous corollary to this idea is this: Poverty is silence. Corporations are very, very wealthy. They have great resources at their command and therefore they can buy a place at the table. Individuals who do not have deep coffers should shut up and mind their own business, which, obviously, they don't do very well or they would have bigger businesses to mind and therefore be prepared to buy a voice. Who would have thought the trick to free speech would be the ability to afford it? 
Maybe I don't understand what free means.
Comments
wedding photographers commented on 07-Jul-2012 10:49 AM
Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on blogs I stumbleupon every day. It's always exciting to read articles from other writers and practice something from their web sites.
Charles commented on 23-Jul-2012 11:44 AM
If corporations have free speech rights, why do they have limited liabilites when they exercise those rights...
easy facebook commissions commented on 28-Jul-2012 10:15 PM
Hi, constantly i used to check web site posts here in the early hours in the daylight, for the reason that i enjoy to learn more and more.
London Business Angels Ltd commented on 31-Aug-2012 08:35 PM
What's up, all is going fine here and ofcourse every one is sharing facts, that's in fact good, keep up writing.
www.quickyquid.co.uk commented on 17-Sep-2012 10:15 PM
this image is without a doubt the number one! quick quid payday loans

Post a Comment




Captcha Image


Recent Posts


Tags

job antisemitic advice Paul Provenza poster The Fresh Citizens United publlish Flashpoint Garry Shandling blog Cat Gwynn synergy hollywood songs Andrew Posner dream Ken Plume Criminal Minds autharium Soylent Green word salad fantasy smodcast poetry commentary Occupy Team Coco Fake Gallery anti-antisemitism memorize sword fighting occupy LA television Sandy Hook school shooting e-publishing solo-show spirit family memory working SCOTUS acting Kelly Carlin Jennifer Worick Marriage Evan Kessler memorization Superman Pitching bigotry, Capitalizm Jack Voorhies reality television security pizza comedy military Jenny Lawson Ron Shock Play Art Supreme Court destination Baltimore upcoming appearance whales Punch in the Face, Things I Want to Punch in the Face novel Sea Glassman blogging Fox Jackie Kashian Wendy Liebman modern depression guidebook intimidation Buena Vista Recommended reading Romance My father Dog entertainment My wife Sir Corwin Disney Andy Sell dog park Greg Fitzimmons KPFK Brian Farrell Sexy Coco longevity Conan O'Brien Corwin wolves sadnesss Let's Pretend This Never Happened conspiracy Chris Bonno Rick Shapiro Ohio Dylan Brody's Neighbor's Couch Huffington Post Dostoyevsky Loveland ebook healthcare Sandyhook Navy potential Fred Stoller corporations Society for Creative Anachronism Van Gogh George Carlin Lora Cain Letter Revolutionary Poets Brigade Twitter Prose humor Ann Randolph Collaboration atheist Alice Radley Amazon Enrico Colantoni review e-book occupy Wall Street labor day published Rain Pryor faith journey travel Health Care nostalgia Facebook The Bloggess story Amy Engelhardt amazon.com Darren Staley CD gig comic books personhood, Citizens United swords wolf Rhonda Shock Laraine Newman Ardent Atheists Thinking Allowed Melinda Hill TV personhood Suzanne Whang buzzwords anniversaries booking revolution Mike Royce antisemite anniversary David Feldman Depression Dylan Brody Talking Stick Dolphins labor KPCC Teresa Powers entertainment industry poem swordplay Alex Stein status quo podcast Safety event

Archive